Wednesday, March 24, 2021

Scot Goes Pop Poll of Polls has Yes ahead on almost 51% of the vote

The last time I published an update of the Poll of Polls, I was startled to receive a series of mildly abusive messages from the Ghanaian Tourism Authority, dismissing any averaging of polls as "bull****".  I must say my past experience of Ghanaian government officials is that they're not usually so psephologically illiterate, so it came as a complete bolt from the blue.  However, I think I managed to reassure them that averaging polls is a long-established practice that generally offers a more accurate sense of the state of public opinion than any individual poll - which might turn out to be an outlier or a rogue poll.  

Here's the latest update now that three more polling firms have joined the fray...

SCOT GOES POP POLL OF POLLS

Should Scotland be an independent country?

Yes 50.8% (-0.8)
No 49.2% (+0.8)

(Based on an average of the most recent poll from each firm - one from YouGov, one from Panelbase, one from Savanta ComRes, one from Survation, one from Ipsos-Mori, one from Hanbury Strategy, one from BMG and one from Opinium.)

So a very slight decline for Yes since the last update in late February, but Yes are still in the lead, and there's no obvious reason to assume that will cease to be the case, given that the last two individual polls have had a Yes majority.

Incidentally, the other thing that puzzled me about my exchange with the Ghanaian Tourism Authority is that they seemed to be excited by any poll that showed Yes down, and disappointed by any poll that showed Yes up.  Given Ghana's history as the first African country to free itself from British colonialism, I'd have expected them to be more favourable towards Scotland's struggle for freedom.  But maybe it's just that the Tourism Authority has gone rogue.

*  *  *

Many hysterical predictions were made about what Alex Salmond would say today, but in the end his statement was restrained, responsible and proportionate.  He hasn't gone after Nicola Sturgeon, he hasn't quibbled about any of the findings from the inquiries that he might disagree with or be disappointed about.  Instead he's homed in on two specific points that it's hard for any reasonable person to argue with - a) Leslie Evans should not still be in office, and b) the person who leaked to the Daily Record should be identified and held accountable for their actions.

I was waiting to hear if there was any mention of Mr Salmond's plans for the election.  The fact that there wasn't probably makes it much less likely that he's going to be standing - but he's a past master of political theatre, so don't rule anything out until the deadline passes.  Even if he isn't a candidate himself, he could conceivably wield some influence by making an endorsement - although personally I doubt whether that would be enough to make any small party a serious contender for seats.  I think he would need to get actively involved himself to have a telling impact.

*  *  *

I had an article in The National yesterday about the new BMG poll putting Yes on 52% - you can read it HERE.

33 comments:

  1. The 'twitter blackface' (assuming the author is in fact white and from the UK) site in question falls into the 'picaninnies with watermelon smiles' style of humor common to Tories in the south of England.

    I personally have no respect for people who hide behind anonymity so they can angrily attack others for, erm, 'hiding behind anonymity'.

    As for the PoP James; I get the same average.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So "Scottish Skier" is on your birth certificate.

      Delete
    2. I'm white. live in Scotland. I ski here. I have African friends and colleagues.

      If I change my moniker to something jokey 'African' LOL, make a pretend African website for a laugh and start mocking people by calling them 'woke' on it, then I would probably lose those friends. Certainly, it would confirm me as a right-winger at least.

      ---

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woke

      Woke (/ˈwoʊk/ WOHK) is a term that refers to a perceived awareness of issues that concern social justice and racial justice.[1] It derives from the African-American Vernacular English expression stay woke.

      Delete
  2. Encouraging to see recent polls trending back upwards so hopefully, with much of the Inquiry shenanigans past and an easing of lock down, that trend will continue.

    The Ghanian thing went straight over my head but I agree regarding Salmond. McKinnon and Evans made a serious mess of the complaints process and ordinarily such a high profile balls up in the Civil Service would see a shuffling of personnel. They might not be fired but they would be taken out of the firing line and moved to where they were no longer the story. That may yet happen before any court case. Can't see the Record revealing its source so unless a third party can prove who it was that is unlikely to come to light.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you. Something rotten in the UK Civil Service and by extension the UK Government have a lot to answer for.

      Delete
  3. Apologies if this is a bit off piste perhaps. I seem to recollect reading somewhere that opinion polls (or some opinion polls) don't generally poll younger people. Is that right? I have been noticing quite a few people posting to the effect that their young relatives are becoming enthused and intending to vote SNP and I wonder if that is factored into current poll results.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, that's not right - the whole point of opinion polls is to have a representative sample. If they don't have enough young people, they upweight the ones they do have.

      Delete
    2. Why would they up-weight James when young folk are allegedly less likely to vote than old folks? This seems to me to be one possible source of great errors occurring.

      Delete
    3. You can still be underrepresented in a poll even if turnout in that group is low. Say 10% of people that actually vote are under 25 but only 5% of your poll respondents are u25. Then you'd upweight that group by making their responses count for double.

      Delete
    4. "Why would they up-weight James when young folk are allegedly less likely to vote than old folks?"

      That's what turnout filtering/weighting is there to correct for. But you have to start with a representative sample of the population, or you might as well just be churning out random numbers.

      Delete
  4. My apologies for a bit of topic.




    For the first time in many months out of sheer nosiness I went and had a quick scroll through WOS. My god what a toxic sewer it is, its like a Trumpian nightmare.
    So sad and needless to say the last quick scroll.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is why the names of complainers in sexual harassment cases are generally kept under wraps, especially when the alleged perpetrator is a very popular, high profile leader type figure in a febrile political atmosphere.

      Also why you might find yourself in court for potentially inciting (intentionally or not) lynch mob nutters to take justice into their own hands by convincing them of wild conspiracy theories while jigsaw identifying those you say are have committed serious crimes (like conspiracy to commit perjury or pervert the course of justice) and are getting away with it.

      It might bring the punters and blog donations in, but someone may end up getting hurt, meaning he judge in the trial will likely turn their gaze on you, especially if you have a large following.

      I suspect Campbell would be getting his ear felt too on this if he'd actually been in the court room and seen the complainers for himself, ergo people would be sure he knew who they were.

      Delete
  5. Why would any one contact you from Ghana about Scottish polling? I think you’ve gone quite barmy

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you're being ironic.

      Delete
  6. A statesman like announcement from Alex Salmond. No ranting, raving or recriminations. A touch of class.

    I cannot blame him for merely wanting a sanction on those who acted reprehensibly, broke the law and were responsible for nearly imprisoning him wrongly for a very long time.

    I do hope that he does get involved in the election and stands so that would give us an alternative to the high-handedness and arrogance of the current SNP leadership with a real prospect of descent representation in the Scottish parliament.

    However, I've being selfish.

    I doubt he will stand given where we are and what's he's been through.

    Despite the current SNP executive writing Alex Salmond out of its history he is the most important figure in the Independence movement to date.

    But the guy deserves a break.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I stopped being at all interested in him after his career choices after being First Minister: A slapstick comedian trying to make jokes about Nicola Sturgeon's tits, and some deeply wierd Russian TV show that involved him romping about a set full of large fluffy rabbits with Ann Widdecombe.

      Delete
    2. He should've become a PR guy for the Uzbek dictatorship like a dignified politician

      Delete
  7. As far as I am aware, the last First Minister of Scotland and Tasmina-ex-MSP-fey-Chelsea have produced unpteen Russian political TV programmes. As far as I am aware, not a single one of the has any import. I may be wrong, but nobody watches it if it still trundles on.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What is it that unionists are always angry and offensive. Did you miss out on a PPE contract from Mike Hancock or some other dodgy deal somewhere else?

      Delete
    2. It's not a question of nats v yoons (0.99 vs. 0.01). Oh Joy? FO. The nationalists are offensive, you unionists are are offensive. Welcome to Scotland. Nobody to blale appart from you, maybe.

      Delete
    3. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  8. Scottish independence voting intention:

    Yes: 49% (-1)
    No: 51% (+1)

    via
    @Survation
    , 11 - 18 Mar
    Chgs. w/ 26 Feb

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. All but 2 weeks old so not much use.

      It's post-Hamilton polls we need now.

      Delete
    2. Holyrood constituency:
      50% SNP
      21% Con
      20% Lab
      8% Lib
      1% Green

      Before Sturgeon was completely cleared / unionists confirmed as liars.

      Delete
    3. The SNP polling 50% at the height of the media frenzy must displease the Whitehall unit stirring it all up.

      Delete
    4. The Yes/No question has Yes at 53% if we rejoin the EU.

      Delete
    5. Why are Survation polls always being released a fortnight after their fieldwork?

      Delete
  9. I see some commenters are a wee bitty unhappy that Yes is still above 50% after the unionists have expended their entire ammo supply.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ah, SK, you need to remember their latest weapon "Put up more butcher's aprons' all over the Scottish colony. That will surely frighten the life out of us Jocks. lol.

      Delete
  10. So what is the Ghana tourism Authority a euphemism for?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Possibly something to do with having a Bathistan account closed and needing a new home??!!

      Delete
  11. Is it anything like Ugandan discussions? Private eye

    ReplyDelete