Alba have put out a brief statement on Twitter confirming that they will not be standing in the forthcoming by-election in Christina McKelvie's old seat. That's not a major surprise, because they've been regularly sitting out the vast majority of local council by-elections, presumably due to a lack of funds and a shrinking, demoralised, demotivated and generally scunnered membership. However, what is interesting in the statement is the crystal-clear assurance that Alba will only be standing on the list in next year's Holyrood election, meaning they will be very sensibly sitting out every single constituency contest.
That's a rare piece of good news from the direction of Alba. Although opinion polls show that it's highly unlikely that Alba will win any seats on the list, they could still have had an impact on the election (and a very negative one) if they had intervened in the constituencies, because they could have split the Yes vote and gifted some marginal SNP seats to unionist parties. For some bizarre reason (actually her incomprehensible stated reason was "being of Salmond blood"), Christina Hendry seemed hellbent on doing just that by standing as an Alba candidate in the ultra-marginal SNP seat of Banffshire & Buchan Coast, where the Tories will start from a very close second place. Her self-indulgent and destructive plan has been deservedly foiled - unless of course MacAskill backtracks on his decision. Some people suspect he may still U-turn, but I think that's become a lot harder for him to do now that he's set out the position so unambiguously.
The chances of retaining the pro-independence majority at Holyrood next year have just increased. Maybe only slightly, but as the Brit Nat ultras at Tesco would say, "every little helps".
Oh come off it, Chris. We all understand why you're making desperate attempts to play to the gallery in the wake of your long-overdue sacking, but there really is no point playing the innocent here. As the disgraced former General Secretary of Alba, you know as well as anyone that the Alba Party does not make decisions by means of "votes". A quaint notion, but nope. You've directly rigged a fair few internal votes yourself over the years, let's not forget.
If all the bad, mad and weird decisions in Alba are made by leadership diktat, it's probably fitting enough that one of the few sensible decisions has been taken in the same manner.
Out of interest, what is the process if a list MSP dies?
ReplyDeleteThey're replaced by the next highest-ranked person on their party's list from the previous election.
DeleteI think the next person on a party's list goes in.
DeleteIs this to force Ash Regan out of the party? Presumably she'd stand as an independent in Edinburgh East.
ReplyDeletePeople have got this strange idea that Ash Regan is required by law to defend her constituency seat. In the real world, her only realistic chance of being re-elected is on the list.
DeleteDoesn't she have a personal vote?
DeleteDoubt it!
DeleteAsh is the laziest of all ALBA members, she has no interest in campaigning on the streets. She doesn't want to defend her seat. ALBA as a party are very lazy , that's why they don't want to stand in constituencies.
DeleteI'm not an Alba member, but I disagree with your claim that Ash Regan is lazy. She is at least a realist, communicates well at voter level and has a good eye for the current issues and how the land lies in Holyrood. She does the grown-up activities and has shown bravery and resilience in Holyrood whereas MacAskill talks too much about his PAST experience, his long relationship with Alex and is hell bent on his 2026 strategy being a copy cat of the 2021 strategy which was a disaster. He says there are more SNP bods moving to Alba, an d A B MacNeil is maybe a good addition - but still the dependency on the nostalgia Alex is top-heavy and he's having to do the 'poisonous Nicola' stuff to gain support from the knee-jerk that way inclined indy movement bods - but he's a gamble for this complete dependence on immersion in the past and depending on negative anti-SNP messaging to get the existing indep. movement bods on side but not expand Alba's appeal outwith the movement - which I suppose is all he needs, but not very ambitious and no refresh. Regan at least is in the present and pushes forwards not backwards.
DeleteAnd Ash R is one of the relatively few MSPs I've seen on independence marches.
DeleteAsh Regan doesn't do anything because she knows she's out at the next election, no amount of campaigning will change that
DeleteShe might flip to Reform though
This "lazy" criticism of Regan is crap. Ash Regan is busy in Holyrood, unlike some of the nodding dogs there. Here's her latest:
Deletehttps://archive.is/UbTq1
Ignore the misleading headline, it looks as though what she wants is a new stretch of road bypassing the Kingsway around Dundee, and since some coming south turn right early and take the back streets, and I've been round both ways, I support what looks to be the DUNDEE NORTHERN RELIEF ROAD:
https://www.transport.gov.scot/publication/strategic-transport-projects-review-report-4-summary-report/j10194c-34/
which of course would have had no chance with the anti-modern BHA.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteQuite right. The last thing we need is data spewing everywhere.
DeleteWarning: the following products may contain nuts:
DeleteJames, have you seen this 'Liberate Scotland' umbrella organisation?
ReplyDeleteApparently Salvo, ISP and a bunch of random indy groups are involved & they're trying to shame Alba into joining them.
Speaks volumes that no one expects or mentions the SNP’s absence from all such efforts. Or the hyper-sectarian Greens.
DeleteAlba to joining Liberate Scotland could mean the kiss of death
DeleteFor Liberate Scotland, you mean?
DeleteIt's a bold and courageous decision. For one, Hendry might take it poorly. Enough to oust MacAskill in order to reverse it? I don't know. There'll be a few others as well.
ReplyDeleteWe saw last year that there are egos who will contest constituencies they have to know were not winnable. Don't have to let them into the marginals like B&B, send them into safer seats.
That has got to be you DAVE FRANCIS! You do know James has some stuff on the back of his site where he can figure out who is who!
ReplyDeleteOT
ReplyDeleteThis is a great article by Marissa MacWhirter (no relation to Iain):
https://archive.is/s8wPn
Young lassie- sounds your the old mysogenist git
ReplyDeleteTake it you are trans then and feeling a bit off after the court ruling.
DeleteThere seems to be a bit of a rash of prepubescent postings on these Alba articles, for some very odd reason.
ReplyDeleteThat would be the WoS rejects and their unionist pals.
ReplyDeleteKindergarten clowns.
Speaking of Wings, the resident cartoonist Chris Cairns has a belter today. His best since “The Path Unchosen” where Nicola took the wrong turn to “Other Stuff” in the first place.
ReplyDeletehttps://i0.wp.com/wingsoverscotland.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/img694.jpeg
Nicola Sturgeon fixation again! Still avoids the other issues
Delete"His best since “The Path Unchosen” where Nicola took the wrong turn to “Other Stuff” in the first place."
DeleteThe problem with that cartoon was that the Rev saw it as encouragement to follow suit.
His cartoons are pretty one dimensional. And only reflect his paymasters wishes. Easy audience to please of course on WOS.
DeleteThe mysogenists need to reflect their unacceptable behaviours
Delete@9:36
DeleteI’m inclined to agree with you. The trouble is, though, Scotgov really did take us down that path. All the madness actually happened.
Sure, indy supporters like you and I would rather the topic was Scotland’s sovereign future, but that’s not where the SNP has taken us since 2014. It’s been mile after mile of Other Stuff.
Back to the UKSC decision, a very thoughtful article in the Herald: https://archive.is/FN89Q "Mark Smith: Men like me need to say sorry"
ReplyDeleteCompare and contrast to the inflammatory article in the National: https://archive.is/jkxvQ - "Mhairi Black: Misogyny underpins this ‘protecting of women and girls’"
In my experience the words "Mark Smith" and the words "very thoughtful" do not fit together.
DeleteMark Smith: After much soul-searching, I have come to the conclusion that Scotland is shit and must be ruled by England forever.
DeleteWhy don't you compare and contrast your Arse Yesindyref
Deletekeaton and Anon at 10:39 AM
DeleteYes, that's the problem. A (previously at least) staunch Unionist is the voice of reason, whereas the Indy activist continues to stir up division, as shown by Pavlov's dog - Anon at 1:24 PM.
That at 5:51 PM was me, yesindyref2.
DeleteAs an Alba member I can say with confidence that there is no way Alba can win list seats while acting as a lone voice. An alliance of independence supporting parties would have a real chance of winning a number of seats. A real independence supporting group in Holyrood could expose the present SNP leadership to public scrutiny.
ReplyDeleteSerious question. Could Alba stand up to serious scrutiny? If even a fraction of what James has revealed is verifiable Alba are wholly undemocratic and fundamentally corrupt. . Would anyone want them associated with the broader Indy movement? And spare me the standard ah but SNP Baaad crap. We are talking about Alba.
DeleteIf we're being blunt though: Outside of the SNP & the Greens Alba is probably the only other one most people have actually heard of.
DeleteEven ISP haven't managed to get themselves noticed and setting up something completely new with a year to go without any big names or massive media attention attached is bonkers. Anyone remember 'RISE – Scotland's Left Alliance' in 2016 and how well they did?
As an ALBA member should you not be attacking unionists and reset your anti snp in all things stance. It seems to me you are out of step with the current political realities. SNP will win Holyrood.
DeleteI agree to an extent but the numbers who have heard of Alba isn’t really the issue. Corrupt and anti democratic are not good selling points.
DeleteThe reason we heard about ALBA is because of the late Alex Salmond and the high concentration of ALBA supporting journalists who are in the National. The small parties should go together for HR election on the list. They might just get the magic % number for the list but could they agree on anything?
DeleteAnon at 11.07pm - " spare me the standard ah but SNP bad crap" you dismiss valid criticism of the SNP but valid criticism of Alba is not dismissed. That just makes you an SNP party person who will accept any crap from the SNP.
DeleteThe reality is they are both crap parties and the politicians and members of both parties have failed Scottish independence. This is despite independence being the highest it has ever been in the polls and Westminster parties continually providing them with great opportunities for independence to succeed.
Anon at 12.08 pm .... not contradicting you but where do you get the notion that the National has a high concentration of Alba supporting journalists?
DeleteLike this Liberate Scotland thing, it's seen in a similar light to if say the Scottish Family Party, Scottish Christian Party and the Animal Welfare Party came together to form an alliance.
DeleteWould the average person on the street care as they tend to only ever be aware of those parties during those seconds they're briefly looking at the other names on the ballot paper?
Liberate Scotland, an anti- SNP alliance.
DeleteAnon at 2.57pm is an SNP drone who is upset that someone is doing something about independence while the SNP ( Swinney) once again promise jam tomorrow.
DeleteYou mean Alba who got 63 votes at Kirkliston or ISP who got 57 votes at Tranent ? 🤣
DeleteIFS at 12.23. Whooooosh. As always your stupidity prevents you from understanding and discussing the issue. You fool no one with your gibberish. You are a sad low level troll. No interest in Indy. Better suited to WOS if they will have you. Off you toddle, silly billy.
DeleteOh good grief! Silly Billy, the troll with the limited vocabulary is back.
DeleteRe the SNP or others being referred to as "pro-independence".
ReplyDeleteThe reality is that the SNP and others are pro-England's Empire for as long as they swear allegiance to the Windsor family and uphold the imperial England's notion that Scotland's independence is subject to Scottish, English, Welsh and N. Irish politicians exercising King Charles' "sovereign" power to grant permission before Scots can even be allowed a decision on independence.
Zzzzzzzzzz. How are things on WOS these days?
DeleteWings is about as useful for Scottish Independence as Trump is for Icelandic self determination.
DeleteI’d take Icelandic strength sovereignty for Scotland any day.
DeleteJohn Swinney yesterday mentioned he was considering a series of independence initiatives starting in Jan 26.
ReplyDeleteOr he could of not scrapped the Constitutional Future Division, the series of independence White Papers or gotten rid of the Minister for Independence.
DeleteSeems to have gone out of his way to stop all efforts that were happening when he took over.
Have you read the White papers? No. Do you know anyone who has? No. Waste of money. Short sharp messaging on specific benefits of Indy is what is needed.
DeleteOptics matter.
DeleteRolling back efforts on indy, not replacing them with anything and just saying you might do something later kinda makes people think that you don't consider it to be a priority.
Anon at 11.29am Why Jan 26th? What year is that?
Deletereally really serious no pissing about this time
Deleteoh yes
believe
The white papers were bland meaningless shite, the Independence Minister was the Invisible Man.
DeleteThink it's worth watching-if you haven't already - Kenny MacAskill's interview on the Holyrood Sources podcast - he's on after Lib-Dem Jamie Greene talking about defecting from Tories to Lib-Dems. MacAskill was asked pertinent questions. Worth a listen.
ReplyDeleteJames, can you clarify for me - are you saying that Christina Hendry is NOT going to try the 'blood of Salmond' constituency seat - but will be standing there on the list? Does she have a realistic chance? I have no measure of her political competence and have only seen her very briefly on vid of Alex's funeral and one other small thing. Is she good?
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure "good" or "bad" is really the criteria here. She's the niece of Alex Salmond, and that seemingly makes her far more important than mere mortals. However, to answer your question, I would say she is articulate but not charismatic. Personally I find some of her views repugnant - she feels that Alba members should shut up about their own views unless they are speaking behind closed doors (and even behind closed doors she would prefer them to shut up). She's strongly in favour of top-down Stalinist "discipline".
DeleteJeesus almighty I have the blood of Franky Stein, who are these nutters?
DeleteToday's Cairnstoon neatly highlights the stupidity and madness that bampots like Chapman, Sturgeon, Somerville, Harvie, Greer, Cole -Hamilton, Sarwar, etc etc foisted upon Scotland. All these politicians need to go away and live out their lives somewhere quite - some dark woods somewhere where they can see bears shitting in the woods and contemplate the shit they have dropped on Scotland. Perhaps one day they may become normal and apologise for all they have done but until then they should just go away and be never heard from again.
ReplyDeleteAll the supporters of this madness over recent years like Scottish Skier need to just shut up about their nonsense. These people have just caused trouble and division for everyone in Scotland.
Bampot Ifs has no self reflection. Maybe he should take some of his own medicine and shut up. We would all be grateful.
ReplyDeleteAnon at 12.55pm - who is this we you claim to speak for? Do you think you are a Royal? Not one of you trolls has actually argued against the points made. You never do - all your intellect can manage is ad hom insults.
DeletePavlov - ring ring
DeleteAnon at 12:55 PM - woof woof
Anon12:55 We would be even more grateful if you would take some time to self-reflect and stop cluttering up the comments section with your bizarre obsession with IFS.
DeleteIfs - the individuals whom you seem to hate are all voted for (rightly or wrongly) to be in their respective positions. I assume you are so detested that you would be hard pressed to vote for yourself. At least that is one saving grace.
ReplyDeleteAnon at 1.01pm - you can assume the moon is made of green cheese for all your post is worth. The only people using the word hate are people like you. You are so stupid that your comment implies that because politicians are voted for at an election they should not be criticised. The reality is that in your mind it’s only the politicians that you like that should be immune from criticism.
DeleteAnon at 12.56pm so you are happy with events over the last 10 years are you. That makes you a Britnat or a fool.
1.01pm - try and read this and remember the contents mr troll. As I have said before the notion of standing in an election to become a politician is anathema to me. Therefore, your comment about me voting for myself is redundant. That pretty much summarises all your ignorant comments.
Deleteanathema to me-- yeh. This just another term for being a cowardly.
DeleteSo says the troll at 2.58pm posting as an anon so that we cannae see it is the same nasty ignorant illiterate troll posting all over SGP.
DeleteBrave "Anon" at 2:58 PM
Delete"anathema to me-- yeh. This just another term for being a cowardly."
The exquisite irony.
IFS will be starting his own political party. There'll be big rivalry between him and Peter Bell.
ReplyDelete2.29pm - absolute dross of a post from a complete diddy. The last thing I would ever want to do is join the ranks of politicians. That old saying that you best keep quiet or you will confirm you are a fool applies to you. You just confirmed it.
Deleteever seen ifs and Bell in the same room?
DeleteSurely Peter has more nonce than ifs. Still IFS wants to criticise but cant stand up to be voted for a diddy party and the diddy men/women/self id
DeletePeter A Bell might be a mental but he's light years smarter than IFS who's still a cave dweller
DeleteThat's a low bar to be honest
Delete@3:01.
DeletePresumably you mean “nous”. Which is ironic, evidently.
Re: Peter Bell and IfS. I’ve no plans to vote for either of them. But I do at least respect them both as fellow Yessers who haven’t scuttled Scotland’s chances like Swinney’s SNP.
One person band with no instrument
DeleteIt's incredible that the ignorant, illiterate troll who has no opinions on anything just keeps on posting abuse and making up stuff. Not exactly normal behaviour. What motivates someone like him? And it will be a he.
DeleteCome on troll tell us more about yourself. Why are you here? What is the point of you. Are you just a weirdo with mental health problems? Are you paid to disrupt by the Britnats? Are you paid by the SNP? Do you just like being a mystery troll? Don't be shy?
" I have no plans to vote for either of them. " Good because you wont be disappointed as I have said many times politicians and political parties are not my thing and there is zero chance of me EVER asking anyone to vote for me. That is just a load of nonsense made up by the SGP resident troll.
DeleteDoes IFS actually believe anyone is fooled? His posts are a description of himself.Take the ones above. Ignorant, illiterate, makes things up, posts abuse. Mental health references. In alliance with the Britnats. It’s IFSs C V. Maybe at long last he is going to get a job and stop sponging off of everyone else.
Delete11.54pm - so you are too shy to say anything about yourself. Do you support Scottish independence? Who knows! You are just a sad troll.
DeleteExplains graffiti found in caves.
ReplyDeleteWhat's a troglodyte like you doing in a cave?
DeleteC’mon your upsetting your neighbours in wealthy east Renfrewshire
ReplyDeleteI see IFS’s anon wee pals (cough cough) are out supporting him tonight. Well done them.
ReplyDeleteI see you are out supporting yourself tonight as you do most nights yet you fool nobody🤣🤣🤣
DeleteAnon at 20.49. Gosh that’s a top notch response, repeating someone back someone’s words. There’s a simplicity to it. Or possibly you?
DeleteNo post at 20:49. Are you illiterate or just inattentive? Anyway it's good to know you're still busy near midnight supporting your own comments.🤣
Delete