Thursday, February 6, 2025

Cos tonight is the night when 1 becomes 2 - has Ash Regan crossed the Rubicon with her resignation and made it inevitable that Alba will split into two separate parties?

Ash Regan, the Alba Party's sole remaining parliamentarian, has given an extraordinary interview in which she reveals that she stepped down from the party's NEC a month ago (despite apparently never having actually attended any NEC meetings!) in protest at the original week-long suspension of Chris McEleny.  Short of announcing their engagement, it's hard to see how Regan and McEleny could make it much clearer that they are mutual allies of each other - any lingering suspicion that McEleny's support for Regan is a one-way thing has been well and truly dispelled.

I heard someone make an interesting point in response to the interview.  They recalled that the action McEleny took against me was initially explained (albeit in extremely vague terms) by a claim that I had breached party confidentiality in a blogpost, although it was never explained what the confidential information was supposed to be or in what form I had disclosed it.  And yet Regan has very explicitly in her interview breached the confidentiality of NEC decisions, and arguably also breached the terms of the party's social media policy by severely criticising the current leadership.  So if consistency is to be maintained, disciplinary action would have to be taken against Regan.  Probably consistency will not be maintained, although who knows - given that the General Secretary is currently taking disciplinary action against the acting party leader, and the acting party leader is currently taking disciplinary action against the General Secretary, anything must be considered possible.  Perhaps every single member of Alba will be expelled, and that's how the party will end.

But it's starting to look like the party will cease to exist in its current form anyway.  The best recent precedent I can think of for such irreconcilable differences opening up within a party is the SDP (Social Democratic Party) in 1987-88, when a narrow majority of members wanted to merge with the Liberals and a substantial minority wanted to remain an independent force.  The SDP leader David Owen actually proposed that there should be an amicable separation, with the party agreeing to divide itself in two and split its resources proportionately.  The pro-merger majority rejected that proposal, but Owen partly got his way anyway - as soon as the merger went through, he simply reconstituted the SDP with the same name, the same logo, himself as leader, and with three of the party's five MPs.  There was also, of course, the UKIP-Brexit Party split in 2018.

I wonder if Ash Regan's resignation is setting in train a similar non-amicable parting of the ways for Alba.  If, as I expect, she loses the leadership election, we might see a new party being set up with herself as leader and McEleny as deputy.  It might attract a significant number of current Alba members due to Regan's feminist credentials.  It sort of half makes sense if you think about it, because it would resolve McEleny's dilemma that we discussed last night - how does he still stand for a Holyrood list seat if he's burned his bridges with Alba?  A new party might be the only way he can do it without renouncing independence and throwing in his lot with Farage.  The new party would even start with a modicum of credibility due to having a serving MSP in Regan, although I doubt that would get them very far.  Alba's current chances of winning seats are slim, but Alba divided in two would surely have no chance.

Alba only have two other elected representatives - the local councillors Chris "Lieutenant Columbo" Cullen in Ayrshire and Karl Rosie in the Highlands.  Cullen is part of the so-called "Corri Nostra" which is backing Kenny MacAskill, so he would undoubtedly stick with official Alba in the event of a split. I've no idea which way Rosie would jump.

85 comments:

  1. The Corrie Nostra? A prize to whoever came up with that one!

    Speaking of names: the Ash McEleny split will need one. My guess is they call themselves The Wings Party because sooner or later someone had to do it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I called it first.

      https://scotgoespop.blogspot.com/2025/02/breaking-chris-mceleny-is-fired-as.html?showComment=1738848787489#c240215162257687299

      Delete
    2. Will Wings/Campbell finance their new Party ( if there is such a thing) and be in charge behind the scenes?

      Delete
    3. I claim my prize!

      Delete
    4. I am the eggman!

      Delete
    5. No, you're not.

      Delete
    6. Corrie Nostra trio ousted Sean and Denise to ensure no threat to them to stand. Cullen in paid position and working with Conservative administration in Ayrshire. Cullen is a cowboy like McEleney.

      Delete
  2. If Regan ends up in the Judean People's Front or whatever she and McEleny decide to call their political love nest, will it be the first time an MSP (or MP) has represented three different parties in one term?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. She will also have ran in leadership contests in two parties, failed in badly in both of them, then quit those beloved parties soon afterwards as well. All while representing the same bewildered constituents.

      If you wanna be a Record Breaker…

      Delete
  3. Does Regan support McEleny’s as a HR MSP?. Either way. This is a complete shambles for ALBA. Seems to me from the outside that Regan knew her attempt to be leader was up and has decided maybe she can be an independent at least until 2026.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am getting lost in the Alba leadership.

    What’s the timetable of the election ?

    Who is the returning officer ?

    When do nominations open ?

    Who is the electorate?

    Who can stand ?

    Will the results be published?

    Basic questions I know many Alba members and supporters are asking ..


    Once those questions are answered maybe we can get into the other points James is discussing .

    ReplyDelete
  5. If I was an ALBA member and paid my dues can I get a refund or go to the polis for branchform 2?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Where’s the missing £6.22? You answer that one, eh?

      Delete
    2. Get the FBI in. Could be a few looking for employment apparently.

      Delete
  6. This is all a bit like Finding Nemo.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I see that, allegedly, McEleny had called for Donald Trump to be made 'Chieftain of the Gourock Highland Games'.
    Weird.
    Who said he wouldn't 'fit" right into Reform?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It would seem he's too busy fitting right into Ash Regan

      Delete
  8. So, is Regan still in ALBA?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's an intriguing philosophical question.

      Delete
    2. Another one: Does Kenny have Salmond blood, now that he's anointed as the departed spirit's chosen one? Is it transubstantiation?

      Delete
    3. Pont d'Allan MademoiselleFebruary 7, 2025 at 12:37 PM

      What is the flag for transubstantiation? I've lost track to be honest.

      Delete
    4. Don’t know but McEleny is still in Reagan ooh err matron. Her judgement is truly appalling.

      Delete
  9. I like Ash Regan too, I hope she stays.

    ReplyDelete
  10. If Ash Regan could've sold her house when she wanted to she wouldn't even have joined the Alba doomsters, now nobody wants her

    ReplyDelete
  11. What is the original source for the interview?
    Where can I listen to or watch the interview?
    Was it just written up? Where is the report of the interview published?
    WHERE man WHERE ?

    I keep six honest serving-men
    (They taught me all I knew);
    Their names are What and Why and When
    And How and Where and Who.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. For the love of God, have you not heard of search engines? It's an LBC interview and pretty easy to find.

      Delete
    2. For the love of facts James, not God.
      Jeezo... I already searched through mountains of Ash Regan interviews
      And it isn't easy to find. Especially if you don't know its from LBC.
      Even then it is not mentioned anywhere on the LBC website or their youtube channel.
      Google search doesn't have it. The only reference to it was via the BBC.

      So ... please provide sources. We all appreciate that it saves readers time, and increases the usefulness and veracity of your work.

      Fortunately the BBC website provides 2 link-outs to their sources.
      "Alba chief suspended over gross misconduct claim"
      https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c9qj3gzxzp2o

      "Chris McEleny suspended as Alba general secretary for 'gross misconduct'"
      https://www.scotsman.com/news/politics/chris-mceleny-suspended-as-alba-general-secretary-for-gross-misconduct-4976726

      and finally, the short video(s) on Twitter from @GinaDavidson

      It seems the video has been clipped into 3 posts on Twitter / X

      'NEW: in the wake of the suspension of Alex Salmond’s close aide Chris McEleny from his role as General Secretary of the Alba Party, @AshReganALBA
      tells @LBC
      she stepped down from the NEC when it first tried to suspend McEleny and says there’s a “leadership vacuum”
      @LBCNewsScot'

      https://x.com/ginadavidsonlbc/status/1887535507216662936

      'How will this affect the party’s leadership election? And what does she think of Kenny MacAskill’s claim that Salmond would be supporting him as leader?'
      https://x.com/ginadavidsonlbc/status/1887537870207856954#m

      'Says she “wasn’t comfortable” with NEC decisions but the “division and backbiting” in the party isn’t helping its chance'
      https://x.com/ginadavidsonlbc/status/1887536218318975011#m


      and two further comment tweets:

      'A statement from the Alba Party in response to Regan's departure from the NEC and the suspension of McEleny: "A disciplinary procedure is ongoing, and we do not comment on internal staffing issues.'

      'The NEC sets the rules for the leadership elections including the designation of returning officers. The party always acts within the law and we do not comment on internal NEC business."'

      Delete
  12. This is rubbish. But if you want to join my new party New Alba I will need you to kiss my ring

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The ALBA Party (MacAskillite)
      New Alba Party (Reganite)
      New Scotland Party (Bellend)

      Not at all confusing for the 0.1% to cast their vote on the regional list.

      Delete
    2. Calnassupyourasses looking for members.

      Delete
  13. It's quite odd that Ash has done this tbh, up until now she could have made out that Chris' support was one way only. She could have even said nothing as a lot of the issues pre-date her joining the Party & just focused on the leadership contest.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Because she thinks she's going to lose.

      Delete
    2. And she wants to lob a grenade into the result while she still can. It's basic preparation for her grand walk-out from the party. Cynical, aye, but more importantly: too late.

      The Salmond family endorsing her opponent was the moment she was nailed-on to lose. She had to react that day. She did not. And now it's all this.

      As little respect as I have for the other operators in Alba, Ash has at least spared them the drama of being led by one of the most remarkable political talents of a generation. And I don't mean a positive one…

      Delete
    3. I mean Kenny is old and getting on a bit. Ash easily could have just taken up a Deputy Leader position and be the obvious choice for Leader next time.

      She doesn't gain anything by leaving and it's doubtful the SNP would treat her well if they even take her back.

      Delete
    4. Q. Ms Regan, why do you wish to join the SNP? Well I want to meet up with my pal Joanna and talk about how I should be Queen of the SNP once I get rid of John. I am very positive about myself and have always supported the parties principles, never said a bad word about anybody,…………. When can I start?

      Delete
    5. One thing I'll give the SNP: at least they didn't purge Jo Cherry. They humiliated her routinely in public, changed the rules specifically to keep her out of Holyrood, and as Anon above refers to: treat her as their pet bogeyman, along with Fergus Ewing. But they didn't drum up fake charges to expel her, like a certain other party. How grown up of them!

      Delete
    6. SNP is better led than Alba and under John Swinney there has been an all hands on deck approach that resprcts and makes use of Jo and Fergus's talents.

      Delete
    7. Ash isn’t that clever. Looks can deceive. Still would :(

      Delete
  14. James in cleaning the stables you were only supposed to “Blow the bloody doors off” looks like you have also brought down the roof and walls.

    Oh dear, how sad, never mind. Many in the SNP will be very glad to have you back. Bigger stables but so much muck!

    ReplyDelete
  15. ALBA. Brought down by James Kelly 2024. Yay!!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Meantime John Swinney has put the SNP on an even keel.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's extremely witty.

      Delete
    2. Can you SNP people make up your mind. Is the SNP the ship for independence or is it the vehicle for independence. It doesn’t give one much confidence in the SNP if they cannot get something as simple as this sorted out.

      Delete
    3. A ship is a vehicle.

      Delete
    4. Big Eater From PerthFebruary 7, 2025 at 11:06 AM

      The NSP is the Maglev of Independence.

      Delete
    5. Witty rhymes with titty ya Fanny.

      Delete
    6. "Is the SNP the ship for independence or is it the vehicle for independence"

      Did they get confused and drive the caravan into the sea?

      Delete
  17. Alba need to be careful. There's a risk this could become farcical

    ReplyDelete
  18. I think it may be time for the ISP. And if they don't have a sane "Partner For Indy" then they'll just have to go it alone
    Cue some sneering comment. But their best performance in a by-election matched the best one by Alba.
    And Alba's star performer? Oh, it was one C. McEleny...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The SNP is better.

      Delete
    2. Can the ISP and Alba save their deposits ?

      Delete
    3. Do you mean "... their best performance in a by-election was just as rubbish as alba's"?

      Delete
  19. Is the ISP pro Brexit?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. https://www.isp.scot/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/ISP-Manifesto-2023-1.pdf

      Page 19.

      Delete
    2. SNP by contrast is pro EU.

      Delete
    3. Thanks for this. Personally I don’t have an issue to be with efta then EU or remain in efta. Independence first. I think ISP pushing land reform would also encourage 2nd voters. ALBA’s views always seemed to be soft UKIP with some tartan braid.

      Delete
    4. ISP policy on EU is not as good as SNPs which is to remain in the EU.

      Delete
    5. "which is to remain in the EU"

      Don't you mean join as a new member?

      Delete
    6. Unless EU allows us in the day after independence the efta is a soft way in. In practice we should ask for the Northern Ireland deal with immediate affect.

      Delete
    7. The biggest issue with ISP imo is that they easily get too distracted on niche issues most people don't care about. Like in your day-to-day life's how often does the oath of allegiance come up in conversation?

      It just seems daft how much time and resources they've dedicated to try and remove it when the easiest path to do so would actually be by achieving independence.

      They also forget that not every independence supporter is also a Republican and we will never every vote possible if it ever comes.

      Delete
    8. Tbh we really need to have a proper debate on EU membership, preferably after indy. Due to Brexit we will need to join as a new member and a lot of people don't realise how long that takes, the requirements to join and we won't have the same terms we had previously.

      If may well be the best path forward but Scots need to be informed properly on what it entails. Most probably don't even know what EFTA is as well.

      Delete
    9. EFTA is nothing very much as all. SNP have the best policy - full membership.

      Delete
    10. Not disagreeing but our mindset has to be with European cousins whether EFTA, Eu.

      Delete
    11. Always felt that ALBA was first and foremost a get SNP, get NS grudge match. Independence was always (as an aside) but the party morphed into some sort of right wing group in with anti rights siding with the tories and co and with an anti European stance. It was more against the SNP than the unionist parties who egged them along.

      Delete
  20. McEleny looks as if he not only ate all the pies - but ate all the pie shops as well.

    Bloated Bellend Balloon.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Stop being personal.

      Delete
    2. Stop touching yourself at night!

      Delete
    3. What a nasty comment.
      Imagine sitting down and thinking that's what I'm going to spend my life doing.
      Oddity.

      Delete
    4. I agree with you at 11:11 AM.

      Just imagine wakening up and thinking, I'm going to be rancid about people I've never meet. 🙃

      Delete
  21. David Francis comes across as a really nice guy.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Trouble at Alba mill.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Secret Army for the Vindication of President JamezFebruary 7, 2025 at 11:14 AM

    President Jamez has become a Scorpion Of Pop.

    Salute your new master!

    ReplyDelete
  24. Talking of Balloons - the wee one in Bath is STILL managing to completely ignore what is happening to the Party set up by his good friend Alec Salmond.
    If an SNP politician farts, he is all over it like a contagious rash.
    Alba implodes???
    Not a single peep.
    'Investigative Journalism' at its best 🤡🤡🤡

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nicola Sturgeon does not deserve to be discussed in this possibly misogynistic way. She made many personal sacrifices to lead the SNP and as a former leader it is only right she be allowed to stand again if she wants to.

      Delete
    2. Scotland is crying out for the cruel but sensuous strap-on-dildo of the chief mammy and lesbo #1

      Delete
    3. Anon at 1203pm- you are a disgrace.

      Delete
    4. He's also an idiot.

      Delete
    5. At least he was not stupid enough to join it

      Delete
    6. Thus showing better political judgement than James Kelly!

      Delete
  25. Campbell right wing pro Brit

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And ignored by 99.9 % of the Scottish electorate.

      Delete
  26. As much as I like Regan's views on independence, I get the impression she isn't very good at small p politics, the day to day, Machiavellian jostling anyone who wants to climb the greasy pole has to stoop to.

    ReplyDelete