As can be easily discerned from the National piece, the charges of "bullying and harassment" McEleny has lodged against Mr MacAskill are totally bogus. They amount to nothing more than special pleading on behalf of the Regan campaign because they didn't like the implications on social media that they were flirting with fascism by aping Reform UK rhetoric. It looks like Mr MacAskill has seen off the bogus action for the time being, with him commenting -
"An unauthorised and unconstitutional attempt was made to allegedly suspend me, Kenny MacAskill, by an individual acting outwith the limits of their powers."
However, those words create a massive problem for MacAskill too, because the words "unconstitutional" and "acting outwith the limits of their powers" have a specific meaning here. McEleny did not suspend Mr MacAskill's party membership pending a disciplinary hearing (which he would have had the power to do under the Alba constitution) but instead sought to suspend Mr MacAskill from attending Alba committee meetings (which he has no constitutional power to do). He specifically said he was empowered to do this due to the precedent of the action he took against me in September, when he initially did not suspend my party membership but instead suspended me from attending meetings of the Constitution Review Group, of which I was an elected member.
By definition, then, if MacAskill is saying that the action taken against himself is unconstitutional and exceeds McEleny's powers, he is confirming that the action taken against me in September was also unconstitutional and exceeded McEleny's powers.
I would suggest it is now incumbent upon Mr MacAskill to clarify whether he voted for or against the unconstitutional action against me when McEleny took it to the NEC. If he voted in favour of it, I would suggest that in all good conscience he should now be considering his own position - not only for knowingly breaching the party constitution, but also for sheer hypocrisy. At the very least, he should be pondering the old verse -
"First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me."
McEleny, for his own utterly selfish ends, has now driven Alba to the brink of either civil war or total destruction, and those who have sat back and allowed him to abuse his powers for the last four years, simply because they were not personally affected at the time, must accept a large share of the blame for that. Morgwn Davies, Alan Harris and myself all did our level best as members of the Disciplinary Committee last year to stand up to McEleny as he maliciously sought the expulsion and suspension of numerous Alba members who had done absolutely nothing wrong - and what support did we receive from senior people in the party who should have been both protecting us and speaking out against McEleny's abuses? None. Absolutely none. We were hung out to dry.
Alba are gonna need a 'Bigger Sack'.
ReplyDeleteI have decided to impose a 25% tariff on Kenny The Mooth's vote.
ReplyDeleteWe can get by without his lawyering.
McEleny needs to go, now
ReplyDelete"We'll have him." - NSP
DeleteUnbridled arrogance on show from McEleny.
ReplyDeleteThe intelligent are the most self-aware.
He shows no self-awareness.
Will Regan and Tamina rush to McEleny’s position or remain silent?
ReplyDeleteHas Regan ever actually acknowledged McEleny?
DeleteIt kinda seems like his support is poisoning her but she hasn't actually linked herself to him?
Kenny’s camp are trying to link Regan with Chris McEleny but there is now reason to and I don’t know why James insists on doing this. Regan had nothing to do with his expulsion
DeletePresumably if Kenny MacAskill wins the leadership it's highly unlikely Chris McEleny will remain in any position of influence (if he even remains a member). Could this be the turning point?
ReplyDeleteNo.There are many ways to fall from a cliff.
DeleteRegan employs mceleney through SG parliamentary budget.
DeleteThat’s a lie Regan does not employ McEleny
DeleteAsk any Holyrood staff who sends out emails from Ash Regan’s parliamentary office -Mr Chris McEleney - it’s not a secret - it’s a fact. He is a regular fixture in the garden lobby.
DeleteWhat an utter shit show Alba are. Can Alba ever recover to be a positive force for independence now - very unlikely.
ReplyDeleteThe only game in town for independence is to get rid of the SNP leadership and replace it with people who actually want independence. If the membership cannot or won't do this it will just be another decade at least of vague statements designed to keep giving the membership a tiny little bit of hope. If they don't get a move on the leadership will have totally captured the party for a long time to come. That means the British state have successfully carried out the only sensible strategy to stop Scottish independence.
Maybe this'll be a creative crisis.
DeleteHere's hoping...
That's up to the SNP not the 1%ers
DeleteIFS: John Swinney's leaderhip of the SNP is good. It has been marked with a steady hand.
DeleteMost people are far more interested in his leadership of the Scottish government than the SNP.
DeleteThey're banning the cats!
Delete🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 3.37pm that’s exactly what ifs said in his post.
DeleteAlso what is all this Swinney steady hand stuff from posters. You really have to question their mentality.
Steady hand - like dead people and those in a coma. Not the best compliment by these silly anons. Hope the SNP are not wasting money paying these posters.
Delete@4:36 Swinney made a great speech at conference. We can all agree.
DeleteI guess that few of the >one in three of the electorate who seem to wish to vote SNP think that Swinney having a rigour mortis hand on the SNP tiller and having made some speech to SNPers is of any import.
DeleteThat minority may well think that the NHS crisis/housing crisis/climate crisis/council funding crisis/higher education funding crisis/all the other crises are entirely the fault of Covid/Westminster/The Martians.
Ho, ho. Rigour mortis hand- what insight, what humour. Not. Martians don’t exist but the greedy exploitation of Scotlands resources and wealth lies in London and the English government.
Delete“They're banning the cats!” Well at least they're not eating them 😱
DeleteIfs- why should the leadership change for someone who is not in the SNP or has any influence on any party or anyone.
ReplyDeleteIs it not obvious to you. The answer is for Scottish independence.
DeleteBut if you're not an SNP member - the SNP are no business of yours whatsoever. There are some in the independence movement these days who stop around like wee generals who think they have some divine right to take over everything and everybody - because they don't have the guts or impetus to start their own party, do the hard slog of standing their own favoured candidates - and convince the public to vote for them. Instead they think they have the right to push around and dictate to everybody else. That's demagoguery in action - it's not about doing anything to get independence. If you really want independence, you'd be out there yourselves showing how your superior to the SNP skills and favoured allegedly better independence candidates can win over the Scottish public, wave your supposed magic 'we can do it better' wand - and get the job done. You're half a job independence supporters if you just want to piggyback other people's work and plot and plan to bring them down thinking in doing so it will somehow elevate you to being anything better.
Delete'Scottish independence' has become an excuse for any under the radar dirty tricks these days to just knock down people you personally don't like - or have pathetic personal grudges against. All these anti-SNP leadership dirty tricks just to mug your way into the SNP and take over what isn't yours in the first place - is exactly the old colonial way of operating - and even if you succeed - nobody but nobody will ever forget how you've gone about - and oh boy - if you manage to drum out these SNP people by this tacky lazy means - your replacement favourites had better give a five-star performance and prove from the get go that they are there for 'independence' and get that result pronto.
Sometimes it looks as if people like yourself who think yourselves so deserving of just getting what you want just because your dirty tricks will get you want you want - will deserve plaudits or be admired for it. You're the people who declare you are the ones who operate with transparency, integrity and all those nice fluffy little attractive terms you use to pedestal yourselves as being better than anyone else. But it's not true is it. You're a bunch of wee generals who think you own Scotland and deserve to rule Scotland and everybody should just bow to your 'well look there, we're going to replace those bods and take over'. That's the British colonial strategy right there. That's exactly how they made their empire and you're after making your own wee Scottish empire.
If that's how you operate to get what you want - it's going to be some wee independent dictatorship you will be setting in motion. The original yes movement was a genuine independence movement. You are displaying entitlement traits which were everything the original genuine independence movement stood against. Those values which were supposed to be what the independence movement was all about.
Self-indulgent overripe molasses.
DeleteWho is that rant at 11.11pm directed against? Is it me because some anon referenced me above or is it Alba or is it just a rant against the world. If it's me then I have no clue what you are going on about but you seem pretty angry.
Delete"But if you're not an SNP member - the SNP are no business of yours whatsoever."
DeleteOh right, aren't we allowed to vote for them then?
I might not agree with IFS on everything, but he and I most certainly have a right to an opinion about any political party, its leadership and its politicians, and a right to express our opinions, including who we think should or shouldn't, be its leader.
You really need to go back to the basics and fundamentals of democracy and do some intense reading. And if you're a member of the SNP with your attitude, you really need to brush up on your "hearts and minds" ambassadorial skills.
A brilliant blog James. Your closing paragraph is apposite. Unless Kenny McAskill sorts out the very things that the 'wee gang of malcontents' were trying to implement through the party's internal processes - amendments to the constitution, policy development, organisation and disciplinary and complaints processes - the party is finished.
ReplyDeleteKenny, let's remember, came 8th when he defended his seat in the general election.
DeleteHe didn't defend his seat, though. He switched to standing in a different constituency. It never made any sense.
DeleteHi James. I suppose the choice of standing for Alloa and Grangemouth in 2024 seemed logical at the time if Kenny and Alba felt their support Grangemouth campaigning was so strong it could not fail to win him the seat. Although - his wanting to be back in Westminster as opposed to waiting and instead aiming for Holyrood surprised me.
DeleteThe only reason I could think the attraction of Westminster would have been, would have been the collaboration with David Davis and continuing to get more sympathetic Westminster intervention clout to progress the 'justice for Alex' intent. That more so than assuming any progress in Westminster could realistically been the route to guaranteeing saving Grangemouth.
I'm assuming it's logical that the Salmond family will need Kenny to be Alba leader first and foremost because being party leader would guarantee him more media exposure - which in turn will further enable many more opportunities to keep 'justice for Alex' in the forefront of the media's awareness - and to keep that fire burning in the public consciousness. (I have no idea if this is perceived as being helpful to Alba as a party in terms of winning votes or not).
In the same way I question whether the Ash Regan article about her being influential in bringing down Nicola Sturgeon and Peter Murrell - was to be considered a vote winner as part of the anti-SNP/anti-Nicola Sturgeon/anti-Peter Murrell narrative and if this was actually Ash's idea - or if her coach convinced her this was a smart move.
Is all of this not just headline grabbing stuff to stir up interest in the Alba leadership contest and therefore the party and therefore 'justice for Alex' - to keep the troops and media interested and engaged after the loss of Alex?
Is somebody jealous of Ash Regan that they feel they have to be seen to pit her against Kenny MacAskill but in such a way that Kenny is seen to be the man of integrity in all things white knight - and Ash is to be made to look as if she was some self-centred vacuous opportunist merely hanging on the coat-tails of Alex Salmond? Which can't be the case - or surely Joanna Cherry wouldn't have mentored her, stalking horse or not, for the SNP leadership contest?
From previous blogposts James, I have gleaned that there seems to be no shortage of individuals in Alba who are capable of causing others grief, collaborating to get rid of people - but is it really likely that Ash Regan would have gone along with Chris McEleny - in this particular way - in order to better MacAskill for party leadership? Or is it not possible that there are others in situ capable also of setting up McEleny to take a fall?
All seems bonkers to me - but presumably there is some sense to be made of it. It's not as if there are not other uncommonly astute strategic players in the Alba party to bring about their desired result - whatever that might be. These things never so easily reach the media at the hands of a stupid person - and it doesn't strike many people that McEleny is that well strategically blessed.
Quite a bit of verbal diarrhoea there at 12.09. Whoops!!
DeleteI doubt Alba can survive as a memorial party for Alex Salmond and remember Kenny got 1.5% in Grangemouth
DeleteKenny stood by while elections were fiddled
Kenny gave No support to NEC members raising same concerns as he raised privately
Kenny is presiding over this current bin fire
These leaks are to damage Ash no doubt coming from someone in Kenny’s camp
It doesn't reflect well on MacAskill, Regan or any of the others that they haven't spoken up. Story's in the Herald as well by the way, leaked email.
ReplyDeletehttps://archive.is/4jgaL
Wonder if McEleny will run as a Reform candidate, when he gets the boot out of Alba???
ReplyDeleteSeems a VERY good fit, to me.
I know some people will say that's far-fetched, but look at it from his point of view. He's highly ambitious, undoubtedly sees himself as a future MSP, so if the option of doing that with Alba is closed off now that his coup attempt has ended in failure, where else does he go? Reform is bound to tempt him because they will get MSPs elected next year.
DeleteWhy would reform want him?
DeleteHis lack of intelligence and integrity?
DeleteReform wouldn't want him.
DeleteOh, behave!
DeleteMy own thoughts exactly, James.
DeleteCouple of others -
1. If, as now probable, Sturgeon does not get charged with anything re Branchform, I reckon that will take the stuffing out of the more ambitious Nicky-Hating Alba Zealots in the Party hierarchy and they might well fly-the-coop to Farage's mob as would-be MSP candidates, rather than hang about in Alba's death throes.
2. The more 'reasonable' Alba Membership, seeing their Party completely implode, will - albeit grudgingly - give their support and votes (if not memberships) to the SNP again.
Reform wouldn't take people from ALBA.
DeleteThey will, if the primary focus of those ex-Albaists is STILL to 'Destroy the SNP'.
DeleteReform might well lap them up.
We dont want him either. We have standards
DeleteWe dont accept anyone with a very low IQ like Chris
DeleteSorry. Too right wing for us
DeleteWe already have plenty Leeks
DeleteAaaaaarrrrggghhhh
DeleteJames, in your honest assessment if Kenny wins the leadership and Chris McEleny leaves the Party would you say that would be a very positive step and could potentially bring the Party back from the brink?
ReplyDeleteAs someone who is now an outside observer, I have been regarding a Kenny MacAskill win as the lesser of two evils, but it has to be phrased that way because McEleny is not Alba's only problem. He's their single biggest problem but not their only one by a long chalk - and some of the other problems can be found in MacAskill's own camp. The list of people supporting him is 'interesting' in places, to put it mildly.
DeleteI once compared McEleny to Beria. I see now that I was wrong; I should have compared him to Acting Grand Nagus Brunt.
ReplyDeleteHe reminds me of the Prebender of Culross.
DeleteJames Kelly deserves a lot of credit for covering what has been going on inside ALBA. His coverage is valuable.
ReplyDeleteIt's just Alba being Alba
ReplyDeleteTheir reason for existence? the destruction of Nicola Sturgeon incomplete, their leader the massive ego gone, all that's left is to melt away and crawl back to Wings over Scotland for instructions as to their next target to be angry with, or will they just end up supporting Reform because Wingsy tells them "They'reee Greattt" vote Reform and independence will happen the day after
Are you suggesting James joined and fought to stay in a Party with that being the reason for their existence?
DeleteAnon at 4.11pm - that is an opinion you expressed but not one that does much to convince anyone to join a political party as it is just tribalism.
DeleteMaybe ISP will step up to the mark? Who are they again?
ReplyDeletePerhaps one sentence snidey remarks will free Scotland anon @4.38pm. If they do people like you will have made a valuable contribution. Pat yourself on the back. Outstanding effort.
DeleteI noticed you couldn’t say who or what they were either.
DeleteMy view is that it is probably better for independence if this latest episode is the final spectacular explosion of the Death Star that represents Alba.
ReplyDeleteThey have become a shambolic embarrassment. Something to be laughed at. A stick for Unionists to beat us with.
Enough! The party died with Salmond.
I say this as somebody who once hoped they would be the alternative force for Indy. A sharp witted, confident list only party that wasn't afraid to push the buttons of SNP careerists and Unionists alike to keep Yes moving along.
It never came close to being like that unfortunately and all that's left now are the death throes of a nasty, spiteful little private club.
I see "fearless journalist" Stuart Campbell is fearlessly ignoring the Alba story yet again.
ReplyDeleteMcEleny is growing into the job and showing a sureness of touch and he made a good speech at conference.
ReplyDeleteAnd then he woke up.
DeleteAlthough it doesn't seem very credible at the moment, if Alba collapses, Reform surges in England, but less so in Scotland, Farage might see some use for an amoral hatchet man like McEleny in Scotland.
ReplyDeleteThey could invent a new title for him - something like Gauleiter perhaps ?
Absolutely I can believe that might happen. He has exactly the buffoonish self importance to go well in a job like that.
DeleteThe Benefits system is the end of human evolution.
ReplyDeleteSomeone too stupid or lazy to have survived and passed on their genes thousands of years ago is now given free shelter, food and healthcare and can have as many children as they want, who will then be tended in the same way their parents were.
I’m guessing you are that superb forecaster called Declan or in other places Skier.
DeleteWhy have you brought Bojo The Clown into this......?
DeleteAnon 831, if you mean the royals you won’t get a peerage.
DeleteA very good point regarding how Kenny voted when McEleny came after you, James. My own guess would be that if he opposed McEleny at that time you would have known about it. As well as that, I don't see him voting against Alex Salmond at that point in time. I do hope, however, that a journalist asks him that very pertinent question.
ReplyDeleteKenny as usual went along with James’ expulsion and the other 2 expulsions
DeleteKenny did not stand up on principle he is weak and is happy for people to be hung out to dry
James if your Alba membership expulsion was unconstitutional does that mean you are really a member of the SNP and Alba at the same time. A unique claim to fame.
ReplyDeleteThe expulsion wasn't unconstitutional - it was totally unjustified, but not unconstitutional. It was McEleny suspending me on an 'a la carte' basis from the Constitution Review Group that breached the constitution.
DeleteAs a protest vote I’ll vote SNP to teach ALBA a lesson.
ReplyDeleteYou’re assuming that Alba are capable of learning lessons. That hasn’t been apparent so far.
DeleteAnon at 11.57pm. The SNP aint very good either.
DeleteWill win HR election. I feel your pain IFS. Your best laid plans and all that
DeleteMcEleny will absolutely try to reach out to Farage and get himself a plum spot on the Reform list. If he manages to do that, I have no doubt that he’ll do what he so spectacularly failed to do in his time at Alba: get elected! He could be quite a gloriously venomous presence in Holyrood. To be honest, he belongs there. We can all name really nasty pieces of work who have reached that place.
ReplyDeleteBut first poor Chris has to get noticed by uncle Nigel. That’s the hardest bit.
Changed days from when back in 2020, on Twa Auld Hieds, Chris McEleny was considered the one to approach to reach out to Angus MacNeil and Joanna Cherry and her staffers about how to go about replacing Nicola Sturgeon. 7 July 2020. But now it seems Mr McEleny has out-stayed his welcome?
Delete'Reach out', not 'contact' but 'reach out'. You know, like any 14 year old girl from Oklahoma would say.
Delete'Nasty and venomous' Farage, Tice and that Tory Defector Twat already sit in WM.
ReplyDeleteYour 'point' caller???
Dave you've been rubbing your wee solider again and we know it makes you angry.
DeleteDAVE is great when angry.
Delete"As long as a hundred of us remain alive, never will we on any conditions be subjected to the lordship of the English. "
Keep it up buddy for Scotland.
12:34 AM
ReplyDeleteCan I reach out to you. I don't want to contact you, just reach out. I'd also like to lean into a laid back vibe.
Best of luck with that apporach to David Francis. Touchy
Deletefeely may work. Never give up on a wayward soul. You have a heart of gold Vacant Twat.
Like it or not James is a force for good. Yes he may be a bit of a lefty but he shines a light on the corruption in ALBA.
ReplyDeleteThe man (on WOS) also has been shining a light on the SNP. Now James has joined the SNP I bet they are welcoming his cleansing light.. I wonder if he will apply the same scrutiny to the SNP as he has applied to ALBA?
Hopefully between the two they can clean the SNP stables out.
For me I'm leaning towards reform.. yes I'm the soft faaacist you have all been slagging off. But see if Reform keep clocking up half a point a month.. I'll let you all know.
But fundamentally I'm a born and breed Scot, country boy too. My family are fishermen (Arbroath) and dockers from Leith. I know we are working class FILTH.. sorry about that. I'm also sorry that I care about Scotland.. but am disgusted about how the SNP have taken us all for a ride to feather their own nests.
Personally I'm thick as fuck. I only have a masters with distinction in Engineering as my basic qualification, my professional qualifications are UK registered so I can't count them.
Let's hope for a new political beginning.