Friday, April 1, 2022

STV for dummies

So no, this is not a reference to Scottish Television dumbing down even further, it's about the other STV, the Single Transferable Vote system which will be used to elect our local councillors in just over a month from now. Several people have asked me if I'll be writing another "idiot's guide" as I did in 2017, because STV has a reputation for being far more fiendishly complicated than just about any other electoral system.  However, that does it a disservice.  The real complexity is actually at the counting end of the system - as a voter, it should be relatively simple to use.  So here's my step-by-step guide to using STV, all the way from deciding your voting choices in advance of polling day, through to how to actually cast your ballot in the polling station.

1) STV is a preferential system, which allows you to rank as many of the candidates as you wish in order of preference - and if you want to maximise the impact of your vote, it's vital to rank as many of them as you can bear to (the "vote till you boak" principle).  That being the case, it's far more important than in other types of election to know how many candidates are standing in your ward, who they are, and what party - if any - they're standing for.  So find the name of your ward (which can often be the toughest part of the process!) and search online for the full list of candidates.

2) Look carefully to see whether each candidate is a Red Code or a Blue Code candidate.  Blue Code candidates are relatively rare these days, but it's important to identify them because the quotient that applies to them is different.

3) If a candidate is Blue Code, they are required by Electoral Commission rules to incorporate a QR code into their election literature.  So when they send you a leaflet, scan the code and it will take you to a website setting out the quotient.  Alternatively, you can search for it manually.

4) On polling day, take your polling card to a polling station and hand it to staff - either that or just tell them your name and address.  (Thankfully, the Tories don't control this election and there will be no ID requirement.) 

5) The staff will then give you a ballot slip.  It will be colour coded if there are both Red Code and Blue Code candidates in your ward.  If there are only Red Code candidates, it will be white.

6) Take your ballot paper to a booth, and start by applying the quotient to all Red Code candidates.

7) If there are Blue Code Candidates, apply the Blue Code quotient separately.  The colour coding should assist you here, but to ensure your preferences for Blue Code candidates are correctly counted, you must ensure that each quotient is applied accurately.

8) Indicate your insistence.

9) Fold the ballot paper and place it in the ballot box.

10) Leave the polling station.

11) As an extra precaution to ensure that no mistakes have been made, re-scan the QR code, and if the quotient has been correctly applied, you should be taken to a page displaying a green "W" and a magenta "7".  

12) Excise the coupon.

And that's it, you're done. 

18 comments:

  1. I want to believe this is your version of April Fool's day! If yes, well done, I almost fell for it!
    Otherwise, I will totally mess up in the elections!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I use the green cross code method.

    ReplyDelete
  3. WTAF - is this a parody?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Is it still the case that Blue Code candidates can only be nominated by the RWM's of two Masonic Lodges, or else by a serving police officer?

    ReplyDelete
  5. And therein lies the problem. The voting system is so complex that people without a degree in statistics or maths can't understand it and either vote 'badly' or are put off voting at all. And we're surprised at the low turn out for council elections.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Remember to invoke the Finsbury Park defence after the third preference, but only if you passed Euston Square.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This voting system should be covered by the Hate Crime Bill as it clearly discriminates against people who are colour blind - shocking.

    ReplyDelete
  8. In my ward i have the following choices
    Diane Docherty (Scottish National Party)
    Craig Edward (Scottish Labour Party)
    Clare Steel (Scottish Labour Party)
    Sophie Traynor (Scottish National Party)
    Liam Wilson (Scottish Conservative and Unionist) i plan to use votes 1 and 2 for the snp candidates should i stop there or should i carry on voting? ie labour 3 and 4 , conservative 5.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If you can differentiate between Labour and Conservative or find a reason (constitutional stance and/or policy position) to commend them then I would recommend ordering them in the order of preference.

      If, however, you don't see anything to mark one out as being better/less worse than the other then I wouldn't rank either of them.

      In my case I only see Con/Lab/Lib as Unionists and this overarching view will inform my decision - I will not place a number against any of them. Only pro-Indy candidates will get a rank from me.

      Delete
  9. Independence For ScotlandApril 2, 2022 at 8:38 PM

    No date for indyref2 before the local elections - well what a surprise. Just how long can Sturgeon get away with this?

    How long will depend on just how stupid the numpties are and it’s looking like they are pretty damn stupid.

    Anyone know where we are on Russell’s 11 point plan? Anyone care?

    Sturgeon will never deliver independence.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Independence For ScotlandApril 2, 2022 at 10:24 PM

    The National reports an increase in Indy staff units alongside a picture of the SNPs very own MacBeth. Good stuff? Oh wait it was on Friday’s front page - April 1st. These jokers are everywhere taking the piss out of the numpties. But didnae worry oor Nicola has a secret planπŸ‘œ.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Brilliant! πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚

    ReplyDelete
  12. Westminster Voting Intention:

    LAB: 42% (+5)
    CON: 36% (+1)
    LDM: 9% (=)
    GRN: 4% (-1)
    REF: 3% (-2)
    SNP: 3% (-3)

    Via
    @RedfieldWilton
    , On 3 April,
    Changes w/ 27 March.

    ReplyDelete
  13. One simple question - as an indy supporter should I rank the unionist candidates at all (even at the bottom of the heap)?

    ReplyDelete
  14. Independence For ScotlandApril 5, 2022 at 1:05 PM

    A COUPLE MORE COLLATIN CRACKERS

    1. “Alba are there to blaken the independence movement.” Is blaken a Scots word? If so what does it mean? Or, as is more likely, he has switched off his spell checker.

    2. “ We will overcome. One day in September 2023.”


    So has the prize Numpty got insider info that indyref2 is next Sept or is he just a Numpty? No prizes for what I think.

    ReplyDelete