Sunday, May 20, 2018

Twitter poll suggests a virtual three-way tie in the SNP depute leadership contest

Just out of curiosity, I decided to run a poll on Twitter yesterday to see how people were planning to vote in the SNP depute leadership election (or how they had already voted).  I genuinely had no idea what to expect, and the final results are pretty remarkable.  With 661 votes cast, there is virtual deadlock between the three candidates, who all have a percentage share in the 30s and are all within 6% of each other.


Now, I'll be honest and say I don't know how much should be read into this.  Obviously a social media poll is a long, long, long way from being scientifically rigorous, because participation is completely self-selecting.  On the plus side, though, Twitter does restrict people to one vote per account, which means the result should at least be properly representative of the views of those who actually took part (ie. it hasn't been significantly distorted by individuals casting multiple votes).

It may be that people who follow me on Twitter are disproportionately likely to be pro-McEleny (and maybe even pro-Hepburn), in which case the poll might be underestimating Keith Brown's true support - although bear in mind that the poll was retweeted by 70 people, which hopefully should have given it a wider reach among supporters of all candidates.  It's also conceivable that social media polls in general are likely to exclude small 'c' conservative members of the SNP, who again might be more inclined to vote for Keith Brown.  However, I still think the poll is a useful exercise, because if the actual result bears no resemblance to the poll result, at least we'll know in future that the balance of opinion on social media is not a reliable guide to the views of the wider membership.

For what it's worth, though, if the actual result is similar to the poll, it seems likely that Julie Hepburn would be declared the winner after second preferences are distributed.  I would imagine that many Chris McEleny voters have done the same thing as me and given their second preference to Hepburn.  If Keith Brown does top the first preference vote, he's going to need a much more substantial lead to be confident of holding on for the win - and that may be true regardless of whether Hepburn or McEleny is his opponent in the second count.

At the very least we can say that there is considerable uncertainty over who is going to become depute leader, and that on the basis of the very limited information that currently exists, it would be foolish to dismiss the chances of any of the three candidates.

11 comments:

  1. Well James as a number cruncher the final result should at least be able to judge who your twitter feed links to different parts of the SNP. As you say its pretty much a statistical dead heat so if someone runs away with it you should be able to judge from that. Why am I saying this thats probably why you posted it. Good luck .

    ReplyDelete
  2. After yesterday's SNP hustings event in Dundee and giving it lots of thought I voted for Chris McEleny.
    I agreed with him on almost everything but what stuck me more than anything was the passion in his voice

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Maybe he knew Jeremy Thorpe!

      Delete
    2. Ah, the wee pet troll's still here...

      Delete
  3. For what it is worth, a similar poll on The National put Chris McEleny pretty substantially ahead and I never noticed that they gave him any particular support ahead of other contenders. It ended up Keith Brown 26%, Julie Hepburn 23%, Chris McEleny 48% out of 787 votes.

    http://www.thenational.scot/news/16235172.POLL__Who_are_you_voting_for_SNP_depute_leader_/?ref=mrb&lp=32

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dilemma - i'd be happy with any of the three.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Three good choices.
    Still undecided, but can't find details of the hustings. Can anybody help?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. https://twitter.com/SovereignWill/status/992861330980966400

      Delete
  6. The new Scottish pound coin will weigh a lot and twice as much as the British coin.Jock pocket billiards will rattle the baws.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I do not have Twitter but I did vote for McEleny

    ReplyDelete
  8. LET'S ALL GO TO BANNOCKBURN !! Saturday 23rd June !!

    ReplyDelete