I'm also pleased to report that there has been much more transparency than there was after the NEC ballot last month, and this time the full results, including every single stage of the complicated Single Transferable Vote count process, have been sent to the candidates. It looks like the intention is that the same full information will be made available to all party members too, although at time of writing that hasn't happened yet.
So I'm returning to the Finance & Audit Committee after a gap of just over a year (I was previously on it as an NEC nominee), and I'm joining the Disciplinary Committee for the first time. On the other hand, I'm no longer a member of the Appeals Committee, which I've been an elected member of since last February, because of course once I was elected to the Disciplinary Committee, I was no longer eligible to be a candidate for the Appeals Committee. So of the four committees/groups I was a candidate for, the only one I missed out on was the Conference Committee - and in the immortal words that Meatloaf very nearly sang, "three out of four ain't bad".
Looking back over the last few weeks, my result in the Membership Support Convener election was probably better than I expected and I came within a whisker of being elected, my result in the ordinary NEC ballot was probably worse than I expected, and my result in these latest committee elections was probably better than I expected. So the lesson is perhaps to always set preconceptions to one side, because each election is a fresh event and there's never any way of knowing which way it will go.
Congratulations to all of the other successful candidates, and I look forward to working with them over the coming year.
Awesome news Jaymes!
ReplyDeleteBrilliant James, fantastic!
ReplyDelete"thank you for the patience of non-Alba readers of this blog"
OMOV has been food for thought. The delegate system indeed favours the well off, the mobile, and those with time to spare. Other parties, the SNP for instance, should take note.
Agreed. A prompt and detailed release of the voting figures is just as good to hear. This stuff must be transparent for every political party. I'd make it required by law, myself.
DeleteNow, don't let that power go to your head. No "work" campervans, you hear? ;)
Good news, good man on the case
ReplyDeleteGood news for you and for Alba.
ReplyDeleteMany hearty congratulations.
ReplyDeletePleased for you James. Well done. Although I said I wouldn't vote Alba in the UK GE ( it probably doesn't make any difference as Alba will probably not be putting up a candidate) as I no longer want to be represented in that House of Horrors in Westminster I still plan to vote Alba at Holyrood elections.
ReplyDeleteThat is encouraging to hear. Thank you!
DeleteGood news James - very pleased to hear this.
ReplyDeleteWatching Kate Forbes at the UK Covid Inquiry is a timely reminder of her abilities. She was appointed out of the blue as Finance Secretary and immediately had to deliver a budget. If that wasn't enough she then had to deal with all the financial issues of the pandemic - which to say the least was extremely challenging but even more so when it involved diddies like Johnson, Hancock, Gove.
ReplyDeleteLooking at the talent in Yousaf's current cabinet it only highlights how he prioritised internal SNP politics over providing the best people to govern Scotland. How many people think Robison is better equipped as Finance Secretary than Forbes. The reason Robison is there is she is part of Sturgeon's gang and Forbes isnae. Personally, I would have Forbes as Finance Secretary not leader - nothing to do with her religion. I just don't think she is that bothered about independence.
I usually agree with much of what you say IFS, however I disagree with you regarding Shona Robison. I think she’s very competent and an excellent Finance Secretary.
DeleteKate Forbes would have Scotland out of the union quicker than you could switch a light off
DeleteForbes states that not only was she not invited to Sturgeon's gold command meetings she didnae even know they were taking place or who attended them. There were no minutes of these very obviously important secret meetings. When eventually Forbes was invited to one she had to ask what is this meeting?
DeleteAnon at 12.07 - I asked whether people think Robison is better equipped to be Finance Secretary than Forbes. Not how you rate Robison.
DeleteCan’t see Forbes being any better than Robison.
DeleteAnon at 12.19pm - that is amazingly quick mr anon. Is that why the SNP members went for Yousaf? Care to explain why and how she would do that as you have explained the when already.
DeleteAnon at 1.07pm - I'll try again - better equipped I said. Beginning to think that ignorant Britnat troll K C is around - I can smell Britnat shit.
DeleteRobison is another one of Nicola's pals. And the common denominator with all of Nicola's pals is they are utterly useless, incompetent morons
DeleteIFS, 🎶🎶🎶🎶 Oh, that’s the way, uh-huh uh-huh I like it 🎶🎶🎶🎶
DeleteIfS: encouraging to read your comments about Forbes.
DeleteWhen John REDACTOR MAN Swinney pitches up in front of the Covid Inquiry I really hope he gets a hard time. He didnae have to redact much this time just deleted everything. This guy showed utter contempt to the Court of Session, the Scotgov's own lawyers, the Scottish Parliament, the Salmond Persecution Parliament Inquiry, the Covid Inquiry and the Scottish public.
ReplyDeleteAlex owes John Swinney for keeping him in a job when he was FM, learn some history before you slag folk off
DeleteThe lying b*****d Swinney acts all apologetic about destroying his messages. Naebody told me that I shouldnae delete them. Naebody told me that the Scotgov policy may be wrong. Bleats Swinney - you were the bloody Deputy FM - you and Sturgeon set the policy. What a pathetic arsehole.
DeleteAnon at 12.21pm - I note you don't dispute any of the points I made in my post.
DeleteIfS: Do you think that if Kate Forbes became leader of the SNP that it would be good news?
DeleteAnon at 4.27pm good news for whom?
DeleteSurely Kate Forbes becoming leader of the SNP could only be good for the party and the independence movement in general.
DeleteIfS: Good news for the SNP in its aim for higher vote share.
DeleteGood news for Kate Forbes. Good news for her church. Good news for the SNP. Good news for the people of Scotland as bampot policies would be right oot the window. Good news for independence in the polls. Good news for actual independence - Ah hae ma doots. Bad news for Sturgeon's gang.
DeleteIfs: Thanks that's encouraging.
DeleteMeanwhile on WGD Proud Cybernat says " VOTE INDY " well that's the point ya numpty we cannae voted for Indy due to Sturgeon's gang taking it off the table. All we can do is vote for a political party or not.
ReplyDeleteJohn REDACTOR MAN Swinney actually thinks that all the UK governments should have been treated as equals during Covid. Delusional nonsense by Swinney and shows how Scotland will never be independent with people like him in charge. Scotland is a colony Swinney and Westminster will never see the "devolved nations" as they call them as equals. Lots of the Tories don't even believe or want devolution but Swinney thinks Johnston should have treated Sturgeon as an equal.
ReplyDeleteCongratulations James. Now, please change ALBA's policy on abstentionism.
ReplyDeleteA difficult one to sell while they still have Westminster seats.
DeleteWGD liar and arch SNP propagandist Irish Skier has, after many years of showing the net rating for politicians, decided in a post to now show only the positive rating without the negative rating netted off it. Why - because Sturgeon is now a nett negative rating and he couldnae possible show Sturgeon having an unfavourable rating so he changes what he is posting. It's pretty desperate stuff by Skier. Suck it up ya nicophant - Sturgeon's popularity is plunging and it has a long way to go yet - way down low - probably even lower than little Sunak.
ReplyDeleteNicola Sturgeon was too socially liberal for me.
DeleteIt went beyond liberalism, more like total insanity with her Pride/transgender obsession - independence wasn't even on her radar.
DeleteCompletely agree!
DeleteIt seems to go from bad to worse for the SNP. Hope it’s no the beginning of the end for them but if is been wondering if through time Alba could become a force and be the main nationalist party, despite the Salmond factor. Or is more likely the SNP could improve radically and return to former glories.
ReplyDeleteSteve P I think that when Kate Forbes takes over things will be better for the SNP.
DeleteAm sure you’re right and it would get better under Forbes, maybe considerably better. She appears to be the obvious one, but then again she was last time and we ended up wi Yousaf.
DeleteI think she will be the next leader. Some time next year. If they tank.
DeleteReally hope so. Because let’s face it: they’re getting scalped.
DeleteTrouble is: Angus Robertson and his missus surely have other ideas. Are the members really so gullible to be conned into voting for EVEN MORE CONTINUITY when the party’s burning in a crater? Place your bets…
Scotland needs so much better than this.
Angus Robertson unlikely to win in debates with Forbes.
DeleteAnon at 10.57 - well Yousaf didn't win the debates but he won the election because the gang wanted him to win.
DeleteIfS: Kate is certainly an excellent debater. If she became leader would you consider voting SNP?
DeleteFocus on independence and many of us will.
DeleteAnon at 12.08am - aye if she delivers a referendum but not a phoney promise like Sturgeon.
DeleteBritish Irish liar Skier and his cronies are talking about setting up a new party if the SNP tank at the ballot box to stop support migrating over to Alba. The Skier Fifth Column party, wonder if they'll get Sturgeon to front it.
ReplyDeleteKate Forbes will take over if they tank.
DeleteI’m going to have the lively and pompous theme song from Ski Sunday on while I follow the returns on election night, in his honour. It’ll make the losses more fun. ;)
DeleteSturgeon at the UK Covid Inquiry tomorrow. Will there be adoring crowds waiting for her wanting selfies or will she get the EGG MAN Murphy treatment. Whatever happens I bet she will manage to forget a lot of things while claiming her Scottish Government is the mostest transparenty government in the whole world. Please not 8 hours of lying this time - keep it down to, say, 5 hours of lying.
ReplyDeleteIt will be interesting to see what you make of her appearance. She is usually very good at these things.
DeleteNo eggs for Sturgeon today but some boos. Certainly no selfies as she shot in to her getaway car. Like Tony Blair Sturgeon is a good actor. Both could convince numpties that they care about them.
DeleteThe SNP/ Alba MPs may make good points in debates but they are ignored. They will never be in power in Westminster. A waste of time in terms of changing anything but their presence provides Westminster with their acceptance of the system and validates Westminster authority over Scotland.
ReplyDeleteThe SNP have settled in NOT settled up. The SNP MPs are part of the Westminster system. Now Blowhard Blackford wants to settle more of them on to the red benches in the House of Lords. Give them another 5 years and expect Lord Wishart of Perth to be enobled along with others for services rendered to the British state.
IFS: Staying away from the House of Commons as a strategy may go down badly with voters and depress SNP vote share. What do you think of this argument?
DeleteAbstentionism would be bold, certainly. I’m not as sold on it as IfS is. I think Nationalists are needed in Westminster: wrecking the system with as much disruption to the gears of state as Scotland’s little portion of the members can provide.
DeleteThe Covid Inquiry and all those TV stations and journalists who got Sturgeon to promise she would keep all her messages are finding out, just like independence supporters, that a Sturgeon promise is worth zero.
ReplyDeleteShe is said by commentators to be a very good communicator so she may be able to get through okay.
DeleteIfS: Alex Salmond has recently criticised Nicola Sturgeon for saying that she would not delete her WhatsApp messages but then deleting them.
DeleteShe is indeed a very good communicator and excellent speaker. Second to none. I expect her to get through this just fine.
DeleteAnon 9.20: agree 100%. She is the consummate politician, par excellence.
DeleteKate Forbes said yesterday she didn't know there was a government policy to delete messages. I've never said she wasn't a slick politician. - so what - so was that other criminal Blair.
DeleteIfS: Would you agree with me that Kate Forbes emerged positively from the inquiry?
DeleteAnon at 10.29am - yes I agree.
DeleteAnon at 9.13am - good for Salmond. At today's Covid Inquiry Sturgeon admitted that when she promised on TV to the C4 news guy she would not delete her Whattsapp messages she had already been deleting them throughout the previous Covid period and continued to do so after making the promise. A brazen liar is Sturgeon.
DeleteJK blogs he's been elected to 2 Alba committees and a group, and all we're getting from the posters is, Nicola Sturgeon, Kate Forbes and John Swinney, what are you lot like, get back on track, the Alba track.
ReplyDeleteThose committees are important and I wish JK every success in his work on those committees.
DeleteTo be fair, James has no obligation to host comments on his blog like my own thoughts on Alba.
DeleteI wish him every success there.
To clarify: I agree with James’s many posts about Alba strategy. If the party took his advice I’d be much more positive about their future.
DeleteSturgeon doing the Hancock trick and starting to get teary eyed.
ReplyDeleteSturgeon desperately trying to convince the UK judge/ KC that she did nothing about independence during the Covid years. They clearly have an agenda to say independence work made Covid worse in Scotland. Some of us know Sturgeon never did anything for independence pre or post Covid.
ReplyDeleteWell done James I voted for you on every committee having had a lifetime of committees I will stick with the National Council! Hugh Kerr
ReplyDeleteMany thanks, Hugh!
DeleteSturgeon morphed from the wee teary wumin in the morning to the Sturgeonator in the afternoon. The Britnat KC got slaughtered in the afternoon. Just the odd lie from Sturgeon this time.
ReplyDeleteBizarre stuff - the Britnat trying to insist Sturgeon was secretly working all the time on Scottish independence during the pandemic and Sturgeon continually saying she wasn't. Obviously, the Britnat started from the premise that any decent independence leader would always be wanting your country to be independent - which is true - but that ain't Sturgeon. She is British and an imposter - to use her own words.
As others have pointed out she managed to easily find her Whattsapp messages re Salmond from years back but today she said she has been regularly deleting them since she was advised to do so in 2007. So not as long a session as in the Parliamentary Inquiry and way way fewer lies but still capable of a lie when required.
Personally I thought N Sturgeon did really well today. It was a long difficult day for her but she deserves a lot of credit.
DeleteHer leadership is sorely missed.
Her leadership? Her adamant refusal to shoot for independence right in front of an open goal!
DeleteAn open goal?
Delete