For those of you who were asking, here is the final result of the 2026 Scottish Parliament election, both in terms of vote shares and seats.
Seats:
Constituency ballot:
Conservatives 11.8%
As we hoped would be the case, this is the biggest pro-independence majority in the Scottish Parliament's history, albeit only just. The 73 seats for the SNP and Greens in combination exceeds the 72 for the SNP, Greens and Margo MacDonald in 2011, the 69 for the SNP and the Greens in 2016, and the 72 for the SNP and the Greens in 2021.
I have to say I am completely and utterly baffled and bewildered by the people this morning who are continuing to moan about what they call "the SNP 1&2 strategy", because for the first time in history those people got what they claimed to want. "Pro-indy tactical voting on the list" ceased to be simply a social media bubble obsession of activists, and was adopted wholesale by the general public in far bigger numbers than ever before. The SNP vote slumped much more on the list ballot than it did on the constituency ballot, and the only plausible explanation is that tens of thousands of SNP-supporting voters tactically switched to the Greens on the list because they'd heard the argument that it would bolster the pro-independence majority. That is precisely why we ended up slightly increasing the pro-independence majority compared to 2021 even though the combined vote share for pro-independence parties on the list ballot actually dropped by several percentage points. As Ailsa Henderson pointed out on the BBC results programme, although the strategy worked a treat this time, the tactical voters were taking an enormous risk because they were making an assumption of how the constituency results would work out, and they could easily have been wrong.
Mark my words: this may come back to bite us in the future. People have a nasty habit of learning the wrong lessons from history, and if there's a kind of 'folk memory' in five years' time that voting SNP constituency, Green list produces a good result for independence, many voters may try to replicate the strategy in an even more risky scenario where the SNP are being seriously challenged in the constituencies. You could easily end up with a dreadful result for the SNP where they finish with ten or fifteen seats fewer than they should have received on a proportional basis, because one-third of their supporters have abandoned them on the list.
Incidentally, don't allow anyone to get away with offering the combined SNP-Green vote share on the list as the definitive vote for pro-indy parties. Although the fringe pro-indy parties such as Atlas had dreadful results in isolation, they did in combination with each other manage to take around 2% of the list vote, and of course there were also pro-indy independent candidates on the list such as Sean Davis, Denise Somerville and Ash Regan. The biggest vote for a pro-indy fringe party was the 0.8% for Atlas, in part due to Tommy Sheridan's name recognition in Glasgow, although Sheridan's own result on the Glasgow list was still relatively poor compared to his previous efforts with Solidarity. The ISP and the SSP (the latter of which most people have probably forgotten even exists anymore) took 0.4% each.
The weirdest quirk of the result is that Labour, in spite of their disastrous reverses, still ended up moving from third place in 2021 to joint second this year. However, they were pipped by a tiny margin in the popular vote on the list ballot by Reform UK. The Greens are now a larger party than the Conservatives, which in historical terms is a mind-boggling thought.
Although the SNP had some wonderful constituency results (Shetland was the stuff that dreams are made of), the two results I found most painful were Na h-Eileanan an Iar and Skye, Lochaber & Badenoch. That is why the SNP list seat on the Highlands & Islands is so soothing - it directly compensates for one of those two defeats and means that one of them doesn't actually matter (take your pick as to which one).
* * *
Please check out the Scot Goes Pop polling fundraiser, particularly if you'd be interested in helping me commission another opinion poll in the future at a moment of maximum impact.
The genius's advocating tactical voting as a strategy are completely wrong headed, if they believe this wins every time in this system and I want to sign them up as goalkeepers for my football team, they'll know every time where the ball is going and they'll never let a penalty in
ReplyDeleteExactly. That's a very good way of putting it.
DeleteI voted SNP + Green, not because I'm a fan of the SNP or Greens, but because I wanted to stop Reform and the Labour Party is such a mess. I was sorry to see that Monica Lennon lost out (I couldn't vote for her) and that three men were elected in Glasgow (surely alternate men and women on the list guys?). The SNP have failed to deliver, especially in the last 5y, but they remain the best of a bad bunch (just).
ReplyDeleteA Scottish Labour Party that is independently organised and funded from English Labour would get my ear, but I'm not holding my breath.
So Stew - you are happy with the Brit state between labour and tories who run Scotland into the ground
DeleteMonica Lennon? Is she a political titan in the mould of Jolly Joanne Lamont and/or Mad Mags Curran?
DeleteThe SNP got 625,000 region votes and that won them a single MSP. That is not a good rate of return on their investment for the electorate.
ReplyDeleteI don't believe the SNP had much of a choice though, can't go down the labour route of ignoring the list vote. Once people start giving their list vote to another party its alot easier for them to switch to that party in the constituency.
I'm surprised you don't mention that IGV took enough votes to prevent a pro-indy MSP in the Mid Scotland region I think it was. It won't effect the parlimentary voting much this time but the electoral commission sitting on its hands about this is concerning.
"The SNP got 625,000 region votes and that won them a single MSP. That is not a good rate of return on their investment for the electorate."
DeleteBut that's not the point, is it. It's not even close to being the point. It was only a 'poor rate of return' because the constituency results were so good, and no-one knew what the constituency results were going to be at the moment they cast their list ballots. When the early constituency results came in from places like Dundee, it looked like Labour were two or three points up and the SNP were thirteen points down. I was thinking to myself "Jesus, on this sort of swing Labour are going to make a few gains in the central belt". If I was reaching that incorrect conclusion hours after the polls had closed, what chance did anyone have of reliably knowing the constituency results when the polls were still open?
As far as Independent Green Voice is concerned, the EC's passive attitude is even more puzzling because I know they gave Alba and Atlas all sorts of grief over names, emblems and slogans. I can only assume it's similar to the mindset that prevents miscarriages of justice from being revisited - once a decision is taken, no matter how obviously bad it is, officialdom just assumes it was right and upholds it.
DeleteGiven Kate Forbes wasn't standing for re-election, the Na h-Eileanan an Iar result was definitely more painful as it ensured there'll be no Gaelic speaking MSPs in Holyrood.
ReplyDeleteI know very little about the guy, but I would imagine it's almost certain the new Labour MSP for Na h-Eileanan an Iar is a Gaelic speaker. Labour have deep roots in that constituency and it's very unlikely they'd risk running a monoglot English speaker.
DeleteIn Skye, Lochaber & Badenoch, the SNP candidate was a Gaelic speaker, so that was the result that has really been costly for the language.
The writing is on the wall, Greens are now winning constituency seats, that will mushroom next time unless SNP are much more positive about setting the case and then demanding independence. SNP vote share has dropped quite a bit and constituency wins were thanks to Reform splitting the unionist vote. I am sorry to admit it but in interviews yesterday Lorna Slater was much more positive about a Greens desire for independence than any of the SNP winners seemed, bar perhaps Stephen Flynn.
ReplyDeleteYour article: "The SNP must go ahead with the Section 30 vote on day one of the parliamentary session - and then when Westminster say no, we move forward to using the 2029 UK general election as the final act of this drama, and to win independence outright"
ReplyDeleteWell done James, we all really need to keep the pressure on them. From the National:
"The First Minister said he still plans to hold a vote on a Section 30 order after the SNP's emphatic victory in the Holyrood election, although the party didn't achieve a majority."
BUT the draft Section 30 MUST be officially drafted by Holyrood to force it into Hansard to put any pressure on at all. A pleading request to Westminster on bended knee don't cut the mustard.
And it must be on the first day of the new term.
There are 26 taverns in Argyll called the Dancing Marionette.
ReplyDeleteThe Western Isles seat loss was clearly down to the ferry scandal.
ReplyDeleteEveryone knows that. What's your point?
DeleteActually the Western isles loss wasn't mainly about the ferries, it was a huge amount to do with Angus Brendan McNeil doing even more campaigning against the SNP than all of their opponents put together, and the misinformation on the stupidity of so called tactical voting
DeleteVote for a pudding and get a sausage claimed the psychics
They lie and they're always wrong on purpose
But people still swallow their crap
This was covered in the podcast by Ponsonby and Massie.
DeleteGood ponsonby/massie this morning.
ReplyDeleteSwinney putting his foot in it already, publicly announcing that he will not cooperate with the Reform MSPs. This follows his catastrophic misjudgement in forcing through an SNP seats/votes only policy, that starting biting him a d the rest of us in the arse the minute the results were known.
ReplyDeleteBBC and MSM are loving it. SNP failed to achieve mandate. Sideline him now and get Flynn in.
There are ferry routes in other areas such as Argyll and North Ayrshire too. Pity CalMac didn’t stand for election and take the flak.
ReplyDelete