MRP Seats projection (YouGov / Sky News / The Times, 23rd March-8th April 2026):
SNP 67
Reform UK 20
Labour 15
Greens 11
Liberal Democrats 9
Conservatives 7
Now, I've estimated the chances of the SNP winning a single-party overall majority as around 1 in 200, and I maintain that it's a long-shot because the voting system is specifically designed to produce hung parliaments. As we saw in 2021 it does that job very effectively indeed. The SNP had a record-breaking 48% of the constituency vote but still fell one seat short of a majority. However, I know there are many disciples of the YouGov MRP method out there, and I don't think it's realistic to pay no heed to YouGov of all firms saying, as they are tonight, that in 89% of simulations the SNP win a majority. Even the lower bound of the estimate has the SNP on 63 seats, which would be only two short of a majority.
Crucially this is not happening simply because of a freakish split in the unionist vote - the SNP's own constituency vote share has recovered to a very healthy 41%, which if true is a great tribute to the leadership of John Swinney.
Another thing I've said repeatedly is that there is no route to an overall majority that involves list seats, and technically this poll even casts doubt on that, because the SNP are projected to take a list seat - but it would be just the one, as Magnus Magnusson used to say. The majority would essentially be won with 66 constituency seats, meaning the SNP would miss out on only seven constituencies:
Shetland Islands
Orkney Islands
Caithness, Sutherland & Ross
Fife North East
Edinburgh North Western
Edinburgh Central
Ettrick, Roxburgh & Berwickshire
Even among those seven, there are some real possibilities for the SNP if the detailed YouGov numbers are to be believed. They're just three points behind the Tories in Ettrick, Roxburgh & Berwickshire, where a big Reform vote could split Tory support just enough to give the SNP an opening. Edinburgh Central is virtually a three-way dead heat, with the SNP and Greens both projected to be on 25%, and Labour just behind on 23%. So in a best-case scenario the SNP may well still hold the seat, and in a worst-case scenario this could be a repeat of 2016 when the Greens handed the seat on a silver platter to a unionist party by putting up a candidate against the SNP - although in this instance the beneficiary would be Labour rather than the Tories.
In spite of the perception that Caithness, Sutherland & Ross may be a lost cause, the SNP are projected to be only four points behind the Lib Dems there. So the only four seats where the SNP would be out of the running completely are the true Lib Dem fortresses of Fife North East, Edinburgh North Western, Orkney Islands and Shetland Islands.
On the other hand, among the 66 constituencies the SNP are projected to win, there are of course some close ones, and none more so than the increasingly weird seat of Dumbarton, which the SNP should have gained from Labour in both of the last two Holyrood elections, but didn't because Tory supporters in Helensburgh tactically switched en masse to Labour. The projection has the SNP winning by a mere two points this time, so to put it mildly that one can't be taken for granted.
In both Aberdeenshire West and Edinburgh Southern I'd have thought the SNP should be regarded as underdogs, but YouGov have them winning both by margins of seven points and six points respectively. That's narrow enough that the results in both seats remain highly unpredictable.
As far as the three Tory "blue wall" rural seats in the south are concerned, YouGov have the SNP taking two, but both are still in the balance: in Galloway & West Dumfries the gap is nine points and in Dumfriesshire it's seven. The Tories are in second place in both, but with Reform playing spoilers in a very close third place.
Banffshire & Buchan Coast has been touted as possibly Reform's most promising seat, but YouGov don't have them even close there: the SNP are on 41%, Reform are on 23%, and the Tories have been pushed into a dreadful third place in territory they held at Westminster level until two years ago.
A couple of other seats the SNP have to worry about are the ultra-marginal East Lothian Coast & Lammermuirs, where they're projected to be just six points ahead of Labour, and also Strathkelvin & Bearsden. The latter really ought to be a reasonably safe seat, but YouGov have the Lib Dems just six points behind. I'm slightly sceptical about that, though - that's an area that traditionally votes completely differently in Holyrood and Westminster elections, and YouGov may be making the mistake of factoring in the Westminster baseline numbers too much. But who knows, maybe this will be the year that the Lib Dems finally break the usual pattern. A leaflet that Ross Greer posted on Twitter certainly gave the impression that Labour were concerned about the Lib Dems in Strathkelvin & Bearsden.
On a more positive note, there's no sign of the close SNP-Lib Dem race in Skye, Lochaber & Badenoch that was suggested by Find Out Now's MRP poll. YouGov have the SNP way ahead of the Lib Dems there by a margin of 46% to 24%.
Last but not least, I should just remind you that MRP projections have a much patchier record in Scotland than they do elsewhere in the UK. For more details, read the piece I wrote for The National a few days ago HERE.
* * *
My latest Holyrood constituency profile for The National is Glasgow Central.
* * *
If you are enjoying Scot Goes Pop's election coverage so much that you start to feel an inexplicable urge to buy me a hot chocolate or a ham-and-cheese toastie, donations are very welcome. There are three main options:
a) you can donate by card HERE
b) you can make a direct PayPal donation to my PayPal email address, which is: jkellysta@yahoo.co.uk
c) you can make a donation by bank transfer - for the necessary details, please drop me a line at my contact email address, which is: icehouse.250@gmail.com
a) you can donate by card HERE
b) you can make a direct PayPal donation to my PayPal email address, which is: jkellysta@yahoo.co.uk
c) you can make a donation by bank transfer - for the necessary details, please drop me a line at my contact email address, which is: icehouse.250@gmail.com
* * *
Over the last few months, I've been building up the Scot Goes Pop channel on YouTube - you can check it out HERE, and don't forget to subscribe.
I do think this poll is slightly 'too good to be true' for the SNP on the constituencies. I'd be shocked if they win Dumbarton and Edinburgh Southern for instance, where there is deeply embedded unionist tactical voting and visible candidates who know their patch.
ReplyDeleteHowever, this is also the first major poll that correctly calculates voter intention on the basis of no green candidate in 68/73 seats - and therefore puts the Greens on 2% of the total consistency vote rather than the impossible 6-11% in other polls. It's no coincidence that the SNP national vote jumps to 41% in this scenario - it's highest since 2023.
Given the past few years, I'd say the SNP getting over 55 seats is a huge victory - and they do seem on track for that at the moment.
Too good to be true as support for SNP continues to lag behind support for Scots Indy and Swinney is utterly insipid. Oh and peddling section 30 BS does nothing for a great many Indy voters.
ReplyDeleteThere are places there I've never heard of.
ReplyDeleteMorning, KC.
DeleteSwinney will be really worried now ... he'll actually have to do something for a change.
ReplyDeleteHe'll be dusting off and tweaking the old pro forma S30 begging letter ...
Poor anon at 1241am -We vote for a party and for Scotland. It seems the "insipid" Fm is gathering the votes in and is likely to be the next FM. Jealousy is never nice.
ReplyDeleteI believe I share your concerns around MRP polling estimates but if this was an accurate snapshot the SNP must be pretty happy. If Edinburgh Central is at risk from Labour and we're expecting Green supporters to turn out in numbers to vote tactically across Scotland for the SNP, is it terrible to ask SNP supporters to vote Green in one Edinburgh constituency?
ReplyDeleteThe SNP decided to put Angus Robertson 4th on the regional list, 1st place is not even a sitting MSP, I think that is an interesting decision.
If SNP supporters want an overall majority, they would be crazy to vote Green in any constituency. Losing Edinburgh Central could well swing the balance.
DeleteAfter past elections I take MRP polls with a pinch of salt. The SNP has to do its utmost to motivate its supporters to turn out on polling say and give the party both votes. If it can do this then there's a chance of a majority but absolutely nothing can or should be taken for granted.
ReplyDeleteVery encouraging. Normally we wouldn’t necessarily expect much to change in the four weeks or so before the election. Understandably folk have other things preoccupying their minds, and some volatility may occur before polls open. Particularly relevant since we’re discussing the constituency seats under first past the post, and margins of victory can be incredibly thin.
ReplyDeleteOn the plus side the SNP have some good candidates in the marginal seats. Edinburgh Southern has dodged the bullet of having Gravy Bus Barbie as their candidate (replaced by the experienced Deidre Brock). Dumbarton has a local councillor running, rather than the allegedly divisive Toni Giugliano.
On the minus side, in constituency seats, the SNP need Reform UK to stay strong (because they are not predicted to win any seats themselves). Unfortunately, Reform UK are on the slide (3% since the start of the year), and as folk pay greater attention to their internal bourach their support may collapse as looks likely happening in Wales where the party is in turmoil.
Only ONE list seat for the SNP..!
ReplyDeleteFrom all those hundreds of thousands of list votes..?
Surely proof (if needed) SNP 1 Green 2 is the only list strategy that makes sense for the independence movement?
That "only" one list seat could make all the difference between winning the overall majority and not winning it.
Delete